927 five-star reviews, more than double any rival.
- 5.0 ★
- 927 Google reviews
- Newest 2 months ago
- Nearby average 4.6
Every recent review is five stars and names specific work: custom engagement rings, an anniversary band, a rebuilt ring, with Janina named in four of five. A third-party page showed 876 Google reviews earlier in 2026, so reviews keep coming; Yelp shows a lower 4.6.
Read the full summary ↓Show less ↑
“Baxter’s is the best jeweler ever! They always go above and beyond to make my pieces perfect! Everyone is friendly and accommodating! They even welcome my Bear, a well-behaved Bernedoodle. He loves going in and getting so much attention! I would not even consider going anywhere else! Thank you, everyone!! Always a fun time!!”
“My husband and I recently had the pleasure of working with Janina to design and execute my 25th anniversary band. It is gorgeous! I’m so pleased with how the ring turned out and as in the past, Baxter’s exceeded our expectations. Janina and the Baxter’s staff were attentive, creative, patient, and professional during every step of this process. Very happy with our experience and highly recommend them!”
“Incredible experience here at Baxter's! I've never been to, not just a jeweler but any business, that has strived so far to make the experience of designing and picking out and purchasing something so incredible. I really can't think Janina and all of the wonderful folks here at Baxter's enough for all their incredible help and patience and time. I can't wait to update this review with pictures! Edit: proposed on a lovely dinner train through Newport, everything was so perfect and we're so happy! Pictures don't do the ring justice, it's lovely and matches her nails just right”
The latest
“Baxter’s is the best jeweler ever! They always go above and beyond to make my pieces perfect! Everyone is friendly and accommodating! They even welcome my Bear, a well-behaved Bernedoodle. He loves going in and getting so much attention! I would not even consider going anywhere else! Thank you, everyone!! Always a fun time!!”
“My husband and I recently had the pleasure of working with Janina to design and execute my 25th anniversary band. It is gorgeous! I’m so pleased with how the ring turned out and as in the past, Baxter’s exceeded our expectations. Janina and the Baxter’s staff were attentive, creative, patient, and professional during every step of this process. Very happy with our experience and highly recommend them!”
“Incredible experience here at Baxter's! I've never been to, not just a jeweler but any business, that has strived so far to make the experience of designing and picking out and purchasing something so incredible. I really can't think Janina and all of the wonderful folks here at Baxter's enough for all their incredible help and patience and time. I can't wait to update this review with pictures! Edit: proposed on a lovely dinner train through Newport, everything was so perfect and we're so happy! Pictures don't do the ring justice, it's lovely and matches her nails just right”
“Baxter's made the custom engagement ring of my dreams! My fiancee and I showed Janina some photos of an inspo ring and described the type of stone I was looking for. It wasn't easy to find due to the shape and coloring I was hoping for (a warm champagne old mine cut stone that didn't face up yellow). She worked with us to get the engraving down pat and we could not be happier. It was also very reasonably priced, as we compared various options and looked at some stones from separate diamond wholesalers too.”
“We had an amazing experience at Baxter’s! I came in with a broken engagement ring that needed to be completely rebuilt and Janina was phenomenal to work with on this. She delivered on everything she promised, and we are very happy with the final outcome. Highly recommend Baxter’s!”
What we checked
- 5.0 average on 927 Google reviews
- All 5 recent reviews are 5 stars, newest 2 months old
- Yelp shows 4.6 stars on 67–76 reviews
- Review link and write-a-review link are on every site page
What’s next?
This report is just the start
Claim Baxter's Fine Jewelry and Keystone stays on it: an assistant that knows this report, the competitors next door in view, and word the moment something moves. Free, no card.